Skip to content
The Record

Compare

Any two entries on identical fields, in identical space.

Standing rule: no scores. Color marks whether something is in force, reversed, contested, concluded, or permanent, not good or bad.

Unscored · 97 entries · last change 2026-08-16
New here? Read this first (30 seconds)
  • Color is a legal fact, not an opinion. It shows (whether something is still in force, was reversed, or is contested in court), never whether it was good or bad.
  • Every number links to its source and to how strongly it can be tied to the action (). Click any figure to see the full evidence.
  • Nothing here is scored, graded, or ranked. When two credible sources disagree, this archive shows both numbers instead of picking one.
  • Wins are in here too. See or filter the Ledger by .
  • Nobody is asking you to trust a byline. There isn’t one — the archive is anonymous, on purpose, which is exactly why it has to be checkable without one. See and check one entry against its own source yourself.

Any two entries, on identical fields, in identical space. Neither column is privileged — the left slot and the right slot render the same way, and the fields are the same for a tax law as for a war. This is how the archive supports comparison without a scoring system: put the records beside each other and let the reader do the weighing.

Left entry
Right entry
One Big Beautiful Bill Act
In force
Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
In force
Date of action
JUL 2025
Date of action
DEC 2017
Domain
Taxes & budget
Domain
Taxes & budget
Unit
Initiative
Unit
Initiative
In force
In force
Status
In force; major provisions phasing in through 2028
Status
Corporate provisions permanent; individual provisions extended by OBBBA in 2025
Verified as of
August 2026
Verified as of
August 2026
Effect claims
3
Effect claims
3
Direct
Direct
Claims marked disputed
0
Claims marked disputed
0
Sourced estimates
9
Sourced estimates
8
3
3
The two headline numbers — $3.4T and $4.1T — are both CBO figures measuring different things (with and without interest, against different baselines). Citing either alone without saying which is a common source of bad-faith argument.
Whether the corporate cut "paid for itself" is settled: no nonpartisan scorekeeper found that it did. Whether the distribution was fair is a value judgment this archive does not make.
Not flagged provisional.
Not flagged provisional.
What this view deliberately does not do
It does not declare a winner, total a score, or order the two entries. Comparing a tariff to a judicial appointment requires a common unit of value, and there isn’t one — any number this view produced would be a preference wearing a decimal point.
97 researched, sourced entries — this is the real archive, not sample dataEvery claim traceable to a primary document or a named estimateCorrections logged publicly, never silently editedNo scores. No rankings. Color marks factual standing only.An independent archive, free to read and free to reuse. No company, no funding, one anonymous maintainer. Full disclosure →Found an error? Submit a correction →
Take the data and check us
Full entry set with standing, attribution levels and every estimate. If you can rebuild this and reach a different conclusion, that is the point.